Superstar of the Year (presenter: Shawn Michaels)
- John Cena
- Randy Orton
- CM Punk
- Daniel Bryan (WINNER)
- Big Show
- Brock Lesnar
- Randy Orton
- CM Punk
- Daniel Bryan (WINNER)
- Big Show
- Brock Lesnar
Diva of the Year (presenter: Eve Torres)
- AJ Lee
- The Bella Twins (WINNERS)
- The Funkadactyls
- Natalya
- Kaitlyn
- Eva Mariе
- The Bella Twins (WINNERS)
- The Funkadactyls
- Natalya
- Kaitlyn
- Eva Mariе
Double-Cross of the Year (presenters: The Shield)
- Triple H costs Daniel Bryan the WWE Championship at SummerSlam
- Shawn Michaels Superkicks Daniel Bryan at Hell in a Cell (WINNER)
- Mark Henry’s “retirement speech” on Raw
- Paul Heyman costs CM Punk the Money in the Bank Contract at Money in the Bank
- Shawn Michaels Superkicks Daniel Bryan at Hell in a Cell (WINNER)
- Mark Henry’s “retirement speech” on Raw
- Paul Heyman costs CM Punk the Money in the Bank Contract at Money in the Bank
Match of the Year (presenter: Bret Hart)
- The Undertaker vs. CM Punk at WrestleMania 29
- The Rock vs. John Cena for the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 29 (WINNER)
- Cody Rhodes & Goldust (w/Dusty Rhodes) vs. Seth Rollins & Roman Reigns (w/Dean Ambrose) with the Rhodes Brothers’ jobs on the line at Battleground
- Triple H vs. Brock Lesnar in a Steel Cage Match at Extreme Rules
- The Rock vs. John Cena for the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 29 (WINNER)
- Cody Rhodes & Goldust (w/Dusty Rhodes) vs. Seth Rollins & Roman Reigns (w/Dean Ambrose) with the Rhodes Brothers’ jobs on the line at Battleground
- Triple H vs. Brock Lesnar in a Steel Cage Match at Extreme Rules
Insult of the Year (presenter: The Miz)
- Stephanie McMahon degrades Big Show on Raw (WINNER)
- AJ Lee disses the “Total Divas” cast on Raw
- Paul Heyman disowns CM Punk
- Zeb Colter offends the Universe
- AJ Lee disses the “Total Divas” cast on Raw
- Paul Heyman disowns CM Punk
- Zeb Colter offends the Universe
“LOL!” Moment of the Year (presenters: The New Age Outlaws)
- The Rock Concert at Raw 20th Anniversary (WINNER)
- Vickie Guerrero is fired as GM of Raw
- Titus O’Neil throws up on JBL, Michael Cole and Zeb Colter on SmackDown
- The Great Khali and Jinder Mahal try to charm Santino’s cobra on SmackDown
- Vickie Guerrero is fired as GM of Raw
- Titus O’Neil throws up on JBL, Michael Cole and Zeb Colter on SmackDown
- The Great Khali and Jinder Mahal try to charm Santino’s cobra on SmackDown
Extreme Moment of the Year (presenter: Mick Foley)
- The Shield Triple Powerbombs The Undertaker on SmackDown
- Ryback spears John Cena through the LED light board at Extreme Rules
- CM Punk exacts vengeance on Paul Heyman at Hell in a Cell (WINNER)
- The Wyatts crush Kane at SummerSlam
- Ryback spears John Cena through the LED light board at Extreme Rules
- CM Punk exacts vengeance on Paul Heyman at Hell in a Cell (WINNER)
- The Wyatts crush Kane at SummerSlam
Fan Participation of the Year (presenters: The Prime Time Players)
- Fandango-ing
- Yes! Yes! Yes! (WINNER)
- Let’s go Cena/Cena sucks!
- What’s Up?
- Yes! Yes! Yes! (WINNER)
- Let’s go Cena/Cena sucks!
- What’s Up?
